Why You Can Trust CNET Coleman Xtreme Rolling Cooler, 50 quarts review: This Coleman cooler is like a cheap suitcase, but for beer
With plastic wheels and a telescoping handlebar, the Coleman Xtreme Wheeled Cooler offers mobility and plenty of capacity -- but the performance was just so-so.
- 10 years product testing experience with the CNET Home team
A cooler that rolls along behind you is a sensible upgrade for anyone who hates carrying things, and at $45, the Coleman Xtreme Wheeled Cooler will get the job done. It isn't the sturdiest piece of plastic I've ever lugged around, but it kept things colder for longer than its closest rival, the Igloo Latitude Rolling Cooler.
Coleman Xtreme Rolling Cooler, 50 quarts
The Good
The Bad
The Bottom Line
That makes Coleman's cooler a sensible pick if you just want a relatively inexpensive wheeled cooler, but consider your alternatives before buying. Though it doesn't have wheels on it, the Igloo MaxCold Cooler offers notably better performance for the same price, and while I haven't tested them just yet, there are wheeled versions available, too. You could also think about saving up for the $400 Rovr Rollr 60 Cooler -- it's awfully expensive, but it offers a rugged, feature-rich design complete with 9-inch inflatable rubber wheels. But if you're willing to settle for middle-of-the-road performance (and if you want to navigate that road without any heavy lifting), then Coleman's cooler is a justifiable pick.
These are the best coolers you can buy this summer.
Click through to see a quick rundown of all of them, complete with links to handy reviews that'll help you figure out which one is worth the cold, hard cash. And be sure to check out our full roundup post, too -- we've filled it to the brim with tips, picks and buying advice.
","image":{"id":"2f65857b-e5c0-48e4-bba1-46b73911515d","filename":"cooler-roundup-promo-pic.jpg","dateCreated":{"date":"2018-06-20 20:11:45","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"alt":"cooler-roundup-promo-pic","credits":"Chris Monroe/CNET","path":"https://www.cnet.com/a/img/hub/2018/06/20/2f65857b-e5c0-48e4-bba1-46b73911515d/cooler-roundup-promo-pic.jpg","cropGravity":0,"crop":null,"caption":"Summer is here, and if you appreciate a frosty beverage on a sunny day as much as I do, then you'll want to be sure to have a dependable cooler on hand. That's why we decided to take a quick break from the gadgets and gizmos of the CNET Smart Home to test out 18 hard-bodied coolers that range from $4 to $400 in price. Our goal? Identify the smartest buys for your buck.
These are the best coolers you can buy this summer.
Click through to see a quick rundown of all of them, complete with links to handy reviews that'll help you figure out which one is worth the cold, hard cash. And be sure to check out our full roundup post, too -- we've filled it to the brim with tips, picks and buying advice.
","height":612,"width":1088,"typeName":"content_image"},"promoTitle":null,"promoDescription":null,"promoImage":null,"typeName":"content_image","typeLabel":"Image","dateCreated":{"date":"2018-06-20 20:11:45","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"dateUpdated":{"date":"2018-06-20 20:11:57","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"datePublished":null,"published":true,"metaData":{"title":"cooler-roundup-promo-pic","caption":"Summer is here, and if you appreciate a frosty beverage on a sunny day as much as I do, then you'll want to be sure to have a dependable cooler on hand. That's why we decided to take a quick break from the gadgets and gizmos of the CNET Smart Home to test out 18 hard-bodied coolers that range from $4 to $400 in price. Our goal? Identify the smartest buys for your buck.
These are the best coolers you can buy this summer.
Click through to see a quick rundown of all of them, complete with links to handy reviews that'll help you figure out which one is worth the cold, hard cash. And be sure to check out our full roundup post, too -- we've filled it to the brim with tips, picks and buying advice.
","alt":"cooler-roundup-promo-pic","created":{"date":"2018-06-20 20:11:45","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"watermark":false,"preferred":false,"start":"","end":"","dimension":"1088x612","size":"182063bytes","type":"image/jpeg"},"slug":null,"status":"PUBLISHED","vanityUrl":null,"author":"ry-crist","topic":null,"authors":null,"wordCount":0,"siteName":null,"sourceApi":null,"objectId":"2f65857b-e5c0-48e4-bba1-46b73911515d","sequence":0,"headline":"","caption":"Summer is here, and if you appreciate a frosty beverage on a sunny day as much as I do, then you'll want to be sure to have a dependable cooler on hand. That's why we decided to take a quick break from the gadgets and gizmos of the CNET Smart Home to test out 18 hard-bodied coolers that range from $4 to $400 in price. Our goal? Identify the smartest buys for your buck.
These are the best coolers you can buy this summer.
Click through to see a quick rundown of all of them, complete with links to handy reviews that'll help you figure out which one is worth the cold, hard cash. And be sure to check out our full roundup post, too -- we've filled it to the brim with tips, picks and buying advice.
","alt":"cooler-roundup-promo-pic","thumbnailCrop":null,"relatedObjects":{"data":[],"paging":{"total":0,"limit":15,"offset":0}},"photoCredit":"Chris Monroe/CNET"},{"id":"30386aec-fcc0-489e-b102-84745a55448d","availableOn":null,"title":"coolers-2","description":"Let's start with the cheap guys. Up first: The Igloo Island Breeze Cooler, which I grabbed on sale at Dick's Sporting Goods for $15. It's about as basic as coolers come, with no latch for the lid and no drainage spout, either, and the performance was pitiful. I say cool your jets and buy something better.
","image":{"id":"319199da-e77f-45d0-b876-9d23388a4971","filename":"coolers-2.jpg","dateCreated":{"date":"2018-06-20 21:28:33","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"alt":"coolers-2-igloo-island-breeze","credits":"Tyler Lizenby/CNET","path":"https://www.cnet.com/a/img/hub/2018/06/20/319199da-e77f-45d0-b876-9d23388a4971/coolers-2.jpg","cropGravity":0,"crop":null,"caption":"Let's start with the cheap guys. Up first: The Igloo Island Breeze Cooler, which I grabbed on sale at Dick's Sporting Goods for $15. It's about as basic as coolers come, with no latch for the lid and no drainage spout, either, and the performance was pitiful. I say cool your jets and buy something better.
","height":1920,"width":3413,"typeName":"content_image"},"promoTitle":null,"promoDescription":null,"promoImage":null,"typeName":"content_image","typeLabel":"Image","dateCreated":{"date":"2018-06-20 21:28:33","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"dateUpdated":{"date":"2018-06-20 21:38:22","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"datePublished":null,"published":true,"metaData":{"title":"coolers-2","caption":"Let's start with the cheap guys. Up first: The Igloo Island Breeze Cooler, which I grabbed on sale at Dick's Sporting Goods for $15. It's about as basic as coolers come, with no latch for the lid and no drainage spout, either, and the performance was pitiful. I say cool your jets and buy something better.
","alt":"coolers-2-igloo-island-breeze","created":{"date":"2018-06-20 21:28:33","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"watermark":false,"preferred":false,"start":"","end":"","dimension":"3413x1920","size":"9709203bytes","type":"image/jpeg"},"slug":null,"status":"PUBLISHED","vanityUrl":null,"author":"TylerLizenby","topic":null,"authors":null,"wordCount":0,"siteName":null,"sourceApi":null,"objectId":"319199da-e77f-45d0-b876-9d23388a4971","sequence":1,"headline":"Igloo Island Breeze Cooler, 48 quarts -- $15","caption":"Let's start with the cheap guys. Up first: The Igloo Island Breeze Cooler, which I grabbed on sale at Dick's Sporting Goods for $15. It's about as basic as coolers come, with no latch for the lid and no drainage spout, either, and the performance was pitiful. I say cool your jets and buy something better.
","alt":"coolers-2-igloo-island-breeze","thumbnailCrop":null,"relatedObjects":{"data":[{"id":"5cdf5ba4-c23e-4590-bba6-141abfa17c08","status":"LIVE","promoImage":null,"slug":"igloo-island-breeze-48-quart-cooler","typeName":"content_review"}],"paging":{"total":1,"limit":15,"offset":0}},"photoCredit":"Tyler Lizenby/CNET"},{"id":"f14e73b2-cac0-4ec9-b4a4-eb0c7e9b800a","availableOn":null,"title":"coolers-10","description":"Rubbermaid doesn't make as many coolers as it used to, but you'll still find a few options if you shop around, including the $20 Rubbermaid Ice Chest Cooler. Like that Igloo cooler in the previous slide, it lacks both a latch and a drainage spout, and the performance was, again, pitiful. In fact, Rubbermaid finished dead last in our tests. Buy literally anything else.
","image":{"id":"7c2bd1ca-10da-49dc-a4f9-3c3aab11c80c","filename":"coolers-10.jpg","dateCreated":{"date":"2018-06-20 22:29:36","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"alt":"coolers-10-rubbermaid","credits":"Tyler Lizenby/CNET","path":"https://www.cnet.com/a/img/hub/2018/06/20/7c2bd1ca-10da-49dc-a4f9-3c3aab11c80c/coolers-10.jpg","cropGravity":0,"crop":null,"caption":"Rubbermaid doesn't make as many coolers as it used to, but you'll still find a few options if you shop around, including the $20 Rubbermaid Ice Chest Cooler. Like that Igloo cooler in the previous slide, it lacks both a latch and a drainage spout, and the performance was, again, pitiful. In fact, Rubbermaid finished dead last in our tests. Buy literally anything else.
","height":1920,"width":3413,"typeName":"content_image"},"promoTitle":null,"promoDescription":null,"promoImage":null,"typeName":"content_image","typeLabel":"Image","dateCreated":{"date":"2018-06-20 22:29:36","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"dateUpdated":{"date":"2018-06-20 22:32:16","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"datePublished":null,"published":true,"metaData":{"title":"coolers-10","caption":"Rubbermaid doesn't make as many coolers as it used to, but you'll still find a few options if you shop around, including the $20 Rubbermaid Ice Chest Cooler. Like that Igloo cooler in the previous slide, it lacks both a latch and a drainage spout, and the performance was, again, pitiful. In fact, Rubbermaid finished dead last in our tests. Buy literally anything else.
","alt":"coolers-10-rubbermaid","created":{"date":"2018-06-20 22:29:36","timezone":"UTC","timezone_type":3},"watermark":false,"preferred":false,"start":"","end":"","dimension":"3413x1920","size":"6153252bytes","type":"image/jpeg"},"slug":null,"status":"PUBLISHED","vanityUrl":null,"author":"TylerLizenby","topic":null,"authors":null,"wordCount":0,"siteName":null,"sourceApi":null,"objectId":"7c2bd1ca-10da-49dc-a4f9-3c3aab11c80c","sequence":2,"headline":"Rubbermaid Ice Chest Cooler, 48 quarts -- $20","caption":"Rubbermaid doesn't make as many coolers as it used to, but you'll still find a few options if you shop around, including the $20 Rubbermaid Ice Chest Cooler. Like that Igloo cooler in the previous slide, it lacks both a latch and a drainage spout, and the performance was, again, pitiful. In fact, Rubbermaid finished dead last in our tests. Buy literally anything else.
","alt":"coolers-10-rubbermaid","thumbnailCrop":null,"relatedObjects":{"data":[{"id":"e2aedf5e-56d2-4e40-8b05-84bb7951f78d","status":"LIVE","promoImage":null,"slug":"rubbermaid-48-quart-ice-chest-cooler","typeName":"content_review"}],"paging":{"total":1,"limit":15,"offset":0}},"photoCredit":"Tyler Lizenby/CNET"}],"paging":{"total":21,"limit":3,"offset":0}},"slug":"which-cooler-should-you-buy-this-summer","title":null,"topic":{"slug":"coolers","name":"Coolers","topicPath":[{"id":"df2361e6-2b67-4c91-b029-bc609f49bea4","name":"Home","typeName":"content_topic","slug":"cnet-home","languages":[{"id":"871c3ea2-550c-4c5f-8cc0-1182b7ceb45b","slug":"cnet-home","typeName":"content_topic_language"}]},{"id":"02b90b2f-5cba-4daa-bae5-58ae0be58f50","name":"Yard & Outdoors","typeName":"content_topic","slug":"yard-and-outdoors","languages":[{"id":"595b73b5-d23a-4131-8b62-33491aeffbb2","slug":"yard-and-outdoors","typeName":"content_topic_language"}]}],"id":"c70c0565-d4fa-4407-baf0-7469b3c2981a","typeName":"content_topic"},"typeName":"content_gallery"}" class="c-shortcodeGallery g-inner-spacing-top-large g-inner-spacing-bottom-large g-border-thin-light-top g-border-thin-light-bottom">Which cooler should you buy this summer? We tested 18 of them
See all photos
The Coleman Xtreme wasn't the strongest performer I found for less than $50, but it got the job done.
The Coleman Xtreme is extreme in name only -- it's just a typical plastic cooler that comes with wheels on it. The lid doesn't latch shut, but you get a telescoping handle and a drainage spout inside, which is more than I can say for cheap coolers like the Igloo Island Breeze and the Rubbermaid Ice Chest. The Xtreme also offers ample room for your beer, claiming a capacity of 50 quarts. Even better, that capacity came in at a bigger-than-advertised 58.1 quarts when I filled it with water to double-check.
As for performance, the Coleman cooler was one of the better options I found for less than $50. When I dropped 3 pounds. of ice into it and recorded the minute-by-minute ambient temperature inside for 48 hours, it pulled temperatures down by about 20 degrees, which is pretty good considering that 3 pounds of ice really isn't a lot.
Still, the Xtreme wasn't nearly as strong a performer as the equally priced Igloo MaxCold Cooler, so keep shopping if you just want something affordable that'll keep your drinks cold the longest. I also wasn't a huge fan of the suitcase-style towing, which forces you to tilt the cooler at an aggressive angle -- the wagonlike, lift-and-pull approach of wheeled coolers like the Rovr Rollr 60 seems like the better design to me. But if you just want something affordable that'll roll from point A to point B and get the job done as far as cooling is concerned, then the Coleman Xtreme isn't a bad pick.
- Want more info on coolers? Check out our full roundup post for more tips and buying advice.